What If Batman Killed the Joker?

The Dark Knight isn’t afraid to skirt the edges of what’s morally acceptable in order to protect the city of Gotham, but he’s always held to one cardinal rule—he does not kill his foes. Except what if he did? What if Batman decided to put an end to the madness once and for all and snap the neck of the Clown Prince of Crime? Would Gotham be better off for it, or would doing so turn the city’s most valiant defender into a murderer no better than the villains he fights?

There are certainly plenty of instances where Batman could have ended the Joker’s life, but let’s focus on the one that many people are the most familiar with. At the end of The Dark Knight, in the final fight between Batman and the Joker, Batman has every opportunity to let him fall to his death. Instead, he catches him. The question remains, however, what kind of world would Gotham be if he had ended the Joker’s reign of terror for good that night?

The seemingly obvious answer would be that Gotham becomes a safer place. The Joker, both directly and indirectly, has taken countless lives, and no matter what prison he is locked in he always manages to escape. Surely his death would mean a better Gotham. The answer, however, isn’t so simple.

You see, the Joker is not the only one with a fragile state of mind. No matter how resolute or just Batman is, the reality is that he is as close to losing control as most of the psychotic villains he faces off against. Shattering the only piece of morality and human nature that he has held on to by killing the Joker would likely push him over the edge. Who’s to say that once the Dark Knight started killing that he could ever stop?

One of Batman’s most famous foes is the Red Hood, Jason Todd. Jason, a former Robin, sees justice differently than Bruce Wayne. His solution to crime is to kill the perpetrator. If Batman were to start playing judge, jury, and executioner just like Jason Todd, what would make him any different from the Red Hood? Killing the Joker, or anyone for that matter, would put Batman on a slippery slope whose end could make him just as much a terror to Gotham as he is a savior.

Ra’s al Ghul and the League of Shadows took a similar approach to justice when they set out to destroy Gotham entirely in order to eliminate the evil that resided there. Batman stopped this from happening, but if the Dark Knight started killing his foes, who’s to say he would not grow to adopt the same vision and belief as Ra’s al Ghul? What if purging the city of all evil meant leveling the city to the ground?

Batman’s no-kill rule is what sets him apart. It defines his approach to justice, and it keeps him human when every other aspect of his lifestyle and mentality threatens to drive him insane. No matter how deserving of death the Joker may be, the truth is that neither Bruce Wayne nor Gotham could afford the consequences of Batman killing him. It’s a paradox that the Joker summed up himself in the Dark Knight when he said “You won’t kill me out of some misplaced sense of self-righteousness. And I won’t kill you because you’re just too much fun. I think you and I are destined to do this forever.”

Like it or not, Batman knew that this was true.

What do you think would be the fallout of Batman killing the Joker? Would Gotham be better off, or would it end badly for everyone involved? Let us know, and show your support for Batman’s unique sense of justice (or the Joker’s unique sense of lunacy!) by sporting one of these great t-shirts!

Batman v Superman (Deadpool Sketch)

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

Team Batfleck

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Super Childish

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

My Hero is Barman

from TeePublic added by
$20 $20.00

Dark Knightmare

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

False God

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

The Fabulous Batman

from TeePublic added by
$20 $20.00

LEGO Batman T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

BatHomer V SuperGriffin

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice

from TeePublic added by
$20 $20.00

Help a friend

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

TSHIRT – Batman V Superman

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

Dost Thou Bleed

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Batsy, batarang thrower T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Bats Loves Supes

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

Gotham Belongs to the Penguin

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Dark knight ARMOR

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Do you Bleed?

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

The Knight vs The God

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Beavis and Buttman

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

Reconciliation

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

Xmas Tree Joker Christmas Jumper

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Dynamic Duo Busted

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Arkham Rhapsody

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Batman is Bruce Wayn…

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Tell Me

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

We Fight Together

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

I AM THE NIGHT!

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Arkham Knight

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Dark Knight

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Check out my new toy!

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

Anti bat Squad

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Clown Prince (of Crime)

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

The Cat

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Arkham Nerd Squad

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

[BvS] The Bat

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

BATTLE FOR JUSTICE

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Dragongirl T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Super Dead

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

Chaos in a pocket

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Batjerk Vs Superdork

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

death in the family T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Xmas Tree Harley Quinn Christmas Jumper

from TeePublic added by
0.00

The Hero We Deserve

from TeePublic added by
$20 $20.00

BITE SIZE MR FREEZE

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

TEAM WAYNE

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

Dawn of Justice

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

Worlds Greatest Fusion

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

Adventure Time Batman and Robin Mashup T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Batbear

from TeePublic added by
$20 $20.00
 

Dark Knightmare

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Harley Quinn T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Agent of Chaos

from TeePublic added by
$20 $20.00

Mad Swing T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Xmas Tree Joker Christmas Jumper

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Let’s Put a Smile on that Face!

from TeePublic added by
$20 $20.00

True Romance!!

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Clown Prince (of Crime)

from TeePublic added by
$14.00 $14.00

Anti bat Squad

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

The Killer Joke T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Xmas Tree Suicide Squad Christmas Jumper

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Suicide Squad

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Chaos in a pocket

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Joker & Harley Quinn

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Joker T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Straight Outta Arkham (Color)

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

I Started a Joke

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Suicide Academy Joker T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Suicide Skull (all team) T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Lovey Dovey Harley ‘Do T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Batman Returns T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Jared Lego T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

I am the one who laughs T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

The Ha-Father

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Joker Boy

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Kraft Punk T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Little Jokesters

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Arkham World

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Suicide Tandem T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Deadshot Suicide Squad T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Time to Make Some Puddin’

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Well-Suited Insanity (Black and White Joker)

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Arkhamvania

from TeePublic added by
$20.00 $20.00

Bizarre Love Triangle – Suicide Edition T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

The Ugly

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Anger

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Birth of a Killer Joke T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Dying Dreams T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Origins

from TeePublic added by
0.00

SMILE

from TeePublic added by
0.00

I'm not gonna kill you T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Harley Quinn hammer time 2 T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Jokerz – Insane Days T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Everything is chaos! T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Smile T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Danced with the Devil? T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Harley Quinn hammer time T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Family

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Joker T-Shirt

from TeePublic added by
0.00

Harley Quinn Suicide Squad Property Of Joker

from Amazon added by

Written by

Hi, I'm John! I'm a science fiction author, freelance writer, and lover of all things creative. Want to get in touch? Feel free to follow me on Twitter or send me a request on Facebook.

Enjoyed this article? It means to me more than you think if you share it!